A year before an arrogant cop named Patrick Pogan assaulted a Critical Mass cyclist in an incident caught on video, several NYPD officers went on a rampage in another Critical Mass ride, jerking people off their bikes before turning on the videographers and photographers attempting to document the abuses.

But enough footage was caught in the 2007 melee to produce the above 12-minute video, which no doubt led to the city to dish out $98,000 to five cyclists in a settlement.

The video contains close-up shots of each suspect’s arrest report, revealing a shocking discrepancy between what took place and what police said took place that night.